Background
1. This appendix contains three sections. Section 1 is a subset of the regional list of plants that occur in wetlands, but includes only those species having an indicator status of OBL, FACW, or FAC. Section 2 is a list of plants that commonly occur in wetlands of a given region. Since many geographic areas of Section 404 responsibility include portions of two or more plant list regions, users will often need more than one regional list; thus, Sections 1 and 2 will be published separately from the remainder of the manual. Users will be furnished all appropriate regional lists.
2. Section 3, which is presented herein, describes morphological, physiological, and reproductive adaptations that can be observed or are known to occur in plant species that are typically adapted for life in anaerobic soil conditions.
Morphological, Physiological, and Reproductive Adaptations of Plant Species
for Occurrence in Areas Having Anaerobic Soil Conditions
Morphological adaptations
3. Many plant species have morphological adaptations for occurrence in wetlands. These structural modifications most often provide the plant with increased buoyancy or support. In some cases (e.g. adventitious roots), the adaptation may facilitate the uptake of nutrients and/or gases (particularly oxygen). However., not all species occurring in areas having anaerobic soil conditions exhibit morphological adaptations for such conditions. The following is a list of morphological adaptations that a species occurring in areas having anaerobic soil conditions may possess (a partial list of species with such adaptations is presented in Table C1):
a. Buttressed tree trunks. Tree species (e.g. Taxodium distichum) may develop enlarged trunks (Figure C1) in response to frequent inundation. This adaptation is a strong indicator of hydrophytic vegetation in nontropical forested areas.
b. Pneumatophores. These modified roots may serve as respiratory organs in species subjected to frequent inundation or soil saturation. Cypress knees (Figure C2) are a classic example, but other species (e.g., Nyssa aquatics, Rhizophora mangze) may also develop pneumatophores.
c. Adventitious roots. Sometimes referred to as "water roots," Adventitious roots occur on plant stems in positions where roots normally are not found. Small fibrous roots protruding from the base of trees (e.g. Salix nigra) or roots on stems of herbaceous plants and tree seedlings in positions immediately above the soil surface (e.g. Ludwigia spp.) occur in response to inundation or soil saturation (Figure C3). These usually develop during periods of sufficiently prolonged soil saturation to destroy most of the root system. CAUTION: Not all adventitious roots develop as a result of inundation or soil saturation. For example, aerial roots on woody vines are not normally produced as a response to inundation or soil saturation.
d. Shallow root systems. When soils are inundated or saturated for long periods during the growing season, anaerobic conditions develop in the zone of root growth. Most species with deep root systems cannot survive in such conditions. Most species capable of growth during periods when soils are oxygenated only near the surface have shallow root systems. In forested wetlands, windthrown trees (Figure C4) are often indicative of shallow root systems.
e. Inflated leaves, stems, or roots. Many hydrophytic species, particularly herbs (e.g. Limnobium spongia, Ludwigia spp.), have or develop spongy (aerenchymous) tissues in leaves, stems, and/or roots that provide buoyancy or support and serve as a reservoir or passageway for oxygen needed for metabolic processes. An example of inflated leaves is shown in Figure C5.
f. Polymorphic leaves. Some herbaceous species produce different types of leaves, depending on the water level at the time of leaf formation. For example, Alisma spp. produce strap-shaped leaves when totally submerged, but produce broader, floating leaves when plants are emergent. CAUTION: Many upland species also produce polymorphic leaves.
g. Floating leaves. Some species (e.g. Nymphaea spp.) produce leaves that are uniquely adapted for floating on a water surface (Figure C6). These leaves have stomata primarily on the upper surface and a thick waxy cuticle that restricts water penetration. The presence of species with floating leaves is strongly indicative of hydrophytic vegetation.
h. Floating stems. A number of species (e.g., Alternanthera philoxeroides) produce matted stems that have large internal air spaces when occurring in inundated areas. Such species root in shallow water and grow across the water surface into deeper areas. Species with floating stems often produce adventitious roots at leaf nodes.
i. Hypertrophied lenticels. Some plant species (e.g. Gleditsia aquatica) produce enlarged lenticels on the stem in response to prolonged inundation or soil saturation. These are thought to increase oxygen uptake through the stem during such periods.
j. Multitrunks or stooling. Some woody hydrophytes characteristical.ly produce several trunks of different ages (Figure C7) or produce new stems arising from the base of a senescing individual (e.g. Forestiera acuminata, Nyssa ogechee) in response to inundation.
k. Oxygen pathway to roots. Some species (e.g. Spartina alterniflora) have a specialized cellular arrangement that facilitates diffusion of gaseous oxygen from leaves and stems to the root system.
Physiological adaptations
4. Most, if not all, hydrophytic species are thought to possess physiological adaptations for occurrence in areas that have prolonged periods of anaerobic soil conditions. However, relatively few species have actually been proven to possess such adaptations, primarily due to the limited research that has been conducted. Nevertheless, several types of physiological adaptations known to occur in hydrophytic species are discussed below, and a list of species having one or more of these adaptations is presented in Table C2. NOTE: Since it is impossible to detect these adaptations in the field, use of this indicator will be limited to observing the species in the field and checking the list in Table C2 to determine whether the species is known to have a physiological adaptation for occurrence in areas having anaerobic soil conditions):
a. Accumulation of malate. Malate, a nontoxic metabolite, accumulates in roots of many hydrophytic species (e.g. Glyceria maxima, Nyssa sylvatica var. biflora). Nonwetland species concentrate ethanol, a toxic by-product of anaerobic respiration, when growing in anaerobic soil conditions. Under such conditions, many hydrophytic species produce high concentrations of malate and unchanged concentrations of ethanol, thereby avoiding accumulation of toxic materials. Thus, species having the ability to concentrate malate instead of ethanol in the root system under anaerobic soil conditions are adapted for life in such conditions, while species that concentrate ethanol are poorly adapted for life in anaerobic soil conditions.
b. Increased levels of nitrate reductase. Nitrate reductase is an enzyme involved in conversion of nitrate nitrogen to nitrite nitrogen, an intermediate step in ammonium production. Ammonium ions can accept electrons as a replacement for gaseous oxygen in some species, thereby allowing continued functioning of metabolic processes under low soil oxygen conditions. Species that produce high levels of nitrate reductase (e.g. Larix laricina) are adapted for life in anaerobic soil conditions.
c. Slight increases in metabolic rates. Anaerobic soil conditions effect short-term increases in metabolic rates in most species. However, the rate of metabolism often increases only slightly in wetland species, while metabolic rates increase significantly in nonwetland species. Species exhibiting only slight increases in metabolic rates (e.g. Larix laricina, Senecio vulgaris) are adapted for life in anaerobic soil conditions.
d. Rhizosphere oxidation. Some hydrophytic species (e.g. Nyssa aquatica, Myrica gale) are capable of transferring gaseous oxygen from the root system into soil pores immediately surrounding the roots. This adaptation prevents root deterioration and maintains the rates of water and nutrient absorption under anaerobic soil conditions.
e. Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions. Some species (e.g. Typha angustifotia, Juncus effusus) have the ability to maintain root growth under soil oxygen concentrations as low as 0.5 percent. Although prolonged (>1 year) exposure to soil oxygen concentrations lower than 0.5 percent generally results in the death of most individuals, this adaptation enables some species to survive extended periods of anaerobic soil conditions.
f. Absence of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity. ADH is an enzyme associated with increased ethanol production. When the enzyme is not functioning, ethanol production does not increase significantly. Some hydrophytic species (e.g. Potentilla anserina, Polygonum amphibium) show only slight increases in ADH activity under anaerobic soil conditions. Therefore, ethanol production occurs at a slower rate in species that have low concentrations of ADH.
Reproductive adaptations
5. Some plant species have reproductive features that enable them to become established and grow in saturated soil conditions. The following have been identified in the technical literature as reproductive adaptations that occur in hydrophytic species:
a. Prolonged seed viability. Some plant species produce seeds that may remain viable for 20 years or more. Exposure of these seeds to atmospheric oxygen usually triggers germination. Thus, species (e.g., Taxodium distichum) that grow in very wet areas may produce seeds that germinate only during infrequent periods when the soil is dewatered. NOTE: Many upland species also have prolonged seed viability, but the trigger mechanism for germination is not exposure to atmospheric oxygen.
b. Seed germination under low oxygen concentrations. Seeds of some hydrophytic species germinate when submerged. This enables germination during periods of early-spring inundation, which may provide resulting seedlings a competitive advantage over species whose seeds germinate only when exposed to atmospheric oxygen.
c. Flood-tolerant seedlings. Seedlings of some hydrophytic species (e.g. Fraxinus pennsylvanica) can survive moderate periods of total or partial inundation. Seedlings of these species have a competitive advantage over seedlings of flood-intolerant species.
Partial List of Species With Known Morphological Adaptations for Occurrence in Wetlands
Many other species exhibit one or more morphological adaptations for occurrence in wetlands. However, not all individuals of a species will exhibit these adaptations under field conditions, and individuals occurring in uplands characteristically may not exhibit them.
| Species | Common Name | Adaptation |
| Acer negundo | Box elder | Adventitious roots |
| Acer rubrum | Red maple | Hypertrophied lenticels |
| Acer saccharinum | Silver maple | Hypertrophied lenticels: adventitious roots (juvenile plants) |
| Alisma spp. | Water plantain | Polymorphic leaves |
| Alternanthera philoxeroides | Alligatorweed | Adventitious roots; inflated, floating stems |
| Avicennia nitida | Black mangrove | Pneumatophores; hypertrophied lenticels |
| Brasenia schreberi | Watershield | Inflated, floating leaves |
| Cladium mariscoides | Twig rush | Inflated stems |
| Cyperus spp. (most species) | Flat sedge | Inflated stems and leaves |
| Eleocharis spp. (most species) | Spikerush | Inflated stems and leaves |
| Forestiera acuminata | Swamp privet | Multi-trunk, stooling |
| Fraxinus pennsylvanica | Green ash | Buttressed trunks; adventitious roots |
| Gleditsia aquatics | Water locust | Hypertrophied lenticels |
| Juncus spp. | Rush | Inflated stems and leaves |
| Limnobium spongia | Frogbit | Inflated, floating leaves |
| Ludwigia spp. | Waterprimrose | Adventitious roots; inflated floating stems |
| Menyanthes trifoliata | Buckbean | Inflated stems (rhizome) |
| Myrica gale | Sweetgale | Hypertrophied lenticels |
| Nelumbo spp. | Lotus | Floating leaves |
| Nuphar spp. | Cowlily | Floating leaves |
| Nymphaea spp. | Waterlily | Floating leaves |
| Nyssa aquatics | Water tupelo | Buttressed trunks; pneumatophores; adventitious roots |
| Nyssa ogechee | Ogechee tupelo | Buttressed trunks; multitrunk; stooling |
| Nyssa sylvatica var. biflora | Swamp blackgum | Buttressed trunks |
| Platanus occidentalis | Sycamore | Adventitious roots |
| Populus deltoides | Cottonwood | Adventitious roots |
| Quercus laurifolia | Laurel oak | Shallow root system |
| Quercus palustris | Pin oak | Adventitious roots |
| Rhizophora mangle | Red mangrove | Pneumatophores |
| Sagittaria spp. | Arrowhead | Polymorphic leaves |
| Salix spp. | Willow | Hypertrophied lenticels; adventitious roots; oxygen pathway to roots |
| Scirpus spp. | Bulrush | Inflated stems and leaves |
| Spartina alterniflora | Smooth cordgrass | Oxygen pathway to roots |
| Taxodium distichum | Bald cypress | Buttressed trunks; pneumatophores |
Species Exhibiting Physiological Adaptations for Occurrence in Wetlands
| Species | Physiological Adaptation |
| Alnus incana | Increased levels of nitrate reductase; malate accumulation |
| Alnus rubra | Increased levels of nitrate reductase |
| Baccharis viminea | Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |
| Betula pubescens | Oxidizes the rhizosphere; malate accumulation |
| Carex arenaria | Malate accumulation |
| Carex flacca | Absence of ADH activity |
| Carex lasiocarpa | Malate accumulation |
| Deschampsia cespitosa | Absence of ADH activity |
| Filipendula ulmaria | Absence of ADH activity |
| Fraxinus pennsyzvanica | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Glyceria maxima | Malate accumulation; absence of ADH activity |
| Juncus effusus | Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions; absence of ADH activity |
| Larix laricina | Slight increases in metabolic rates; increased levels of nitrate reductase |
| Lobelia dortmanna | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Lythrum salicaria | Absence of ADH activity |
| Molinia caerulea | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Myrica gale | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Nuphar lutea | Organic acid production |
| Nyssa aquatica | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Nyssa sylvatica var. biflora | Oxidizes the rhizosphere; malate accumulation |
| Phalaris arundinacea | Absence of ADH activity; ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |
| Phragmites australis | Malate accumulation |
| Pinus contorta | Slight increases in metabolic rates; increased levels of nitrate reductase |
| Polygonum amphibium | Absence of ADH activity |
| Potentilla anserina | Absence of ADH activity; ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |
| Ranunculus flammula | Malate accumulation; absence of ADH activity |
| Salix cinerea | Malate accumulation |
| Salix fragilis | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Salix lasiolepis | Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |
| Scirpus maritimus | Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |
| Senecio vulgaris | Slight increases in metabolic rates |
| Spartina alterniflora | Oxidizes the rhizosphere |
| Trifoliun subterraneum | Low ADH activity |
| Typha angustifolia | Ability for root growth in low oxygen tensions |